Buy the book!

Ghosts of World War Two

Here's a great way to illustrate history, using Photoshop.

Plato's Cave: A Model of What a Learning Object Should Be

The Washington Teacher Purges

Teachers are unpopular enough these days that many, especially on the right, are cheering the recent firing of 241 teachers by Michelle Rhee in Washington, DC, for being "ineffective."

I am not. It is a scam. The whole push to "reform" the Washington system is in lieu of introducing school vouchers. It is not a bold initiative to improve the education system, but a rearguard effort to preserve the status quo.

Out of the 241 given pink slips, 76 were fired for "lack of teaching credentials."

In other words, for not being part of the union. What does it mean to be a "qualified teacher"? Are we justified in paying extra for schools to ensure that our children are taught by one?

As previously noted in this space, students who take "education" degrees score lower than any other college major, with the possible exception of "public administration," on the SAT or GRE. So if there is selection or weeding out going on here, it is weeding out of the best and the brightest.

But that is only half the story. Once they get to Ed School, is it rigorous? Is there any weeding out at that level?

Apparently not, according to a study by George K. Cunningham for the Pope Centre ("University of North Carolina Education Schools: Helping or Hindering Potential Teachers?" January, 2008).

Page 16 features a chart of average GPAs nationally, in the US, for different academic disciplines. The lower the score, obviously, the tougher it is to get good marks in that field. Average GPA for engineering: 2.67. Average GPA for math: 2.68. Social science: 2.96. Humanities: 3.06 (I suspect it would have been lower before the humanities went ideological). Education: 3.41. You gotta do something seriously wrong to get a B. Pile this on top of the fact that ed students are the weakest students to begin with, and it is hard to conceive of anyone managing to flunk out of an education program, on academic grounds.

And that seems to be the case. Page 19 shows a table of pass rates for all the Ed Schools in the state of Vermont. Range, average, mean, it's all the same: 100% Every single student in the state graduates.

All this means not just that our "qualified teachers" are not qualified; it means that anyone at all bright going into the field has to be consciously cynical, has to deliberately sell out. What do they learn in Ed Schools? Mostly, I suspect, to hew to an ideological line, key to which is the political solidarity of the teaching profession. It's all kind of like joining Hell's Angels, or the Mafia.

Are these the people we want in charge of our children? Perhaps not...

Those worst served by this form of teacher qualification, I suspect, are the brightest students. Teaching has a natural appeal to those with fantasies of power and control; and it is fallen human nature to resent those who are smarter than we are. Accordingly, the sort of folks who go into the field are liable often to be downright hostile to the gifted; others have remarked on a distinct tendency within the education establishment of anti-intellectualism, indeed of hostility toward any form of merit or meritocracy.

Accordingly, this mass firing has probably weeded out the better, not the worse, teachers.

Never mind; that's only 76 out of 241. That leaves 165 teachers who were fired for actual poor performance in the classroom, right?

Not necessarily. The rest were fired because they were marked poorly on classroom observations, or because their students failed to improve on standardized tests; but the DC administration cannot give figures for each category. This fact is in itself highly suspicious.

This matters. Unfortunately, classroom observations, although widely popular with the educational establishment, are unable to reliably identity good or bad teachers. Repeated studies show they only determine whether the observed teacher conforms to the teaching practices of the person observing; two different observers will commonly give two completely different evaluations. This is necessarily so, because we really do not know what traits produce the best classroom results.

Why, then, are they so popular? Because they too enforce the cartel of the Ed Schools. Given that the person observing will inevitably be himself or herself a product of an Ed School, their mark will simply reflect whether the person teaching has also attended Ed School, and teaches in the currently prescribed manner. The test is valid only if the methods of the Ed Schools can be shown to be valid; and they cannot. Studies consistently show that an Ed School grad gets no better results with a given class than an educated layman.

The only valid criterion mentioned in the story is how the students do on standardized tests. But we have no idea how many teachers, if any, were actually fired for this reason. And, of course, standardized tests too can be jimmied to some extent. Even if they are not, student test scores are a fairly rough measure of teacher competence--even over three years teaching the same course, the error rate is arguably as high as 25%.

A more perfect criterion, and a far simpler one, is simply this: let the market decide. Let families (and students) choose the school and teacher for their child, using whatever criteria they see fit. It is this criterion that all the recent sound and fury in Washington has actually been designed to avoid.

Diversity and Merit

The current official justification for "affirmative action"--that is, racial discrimination--in university admissions in the US is that it is needed in order to create "diversity." "Diversity" in turn is held to be an important learning goal. There is no justification in terms of righting past wrongs--first, such past wrongs were done to other people, not the ones now advantaged; and second, such programs do not discriminate between more recent immigrants, whose ancestors were never discriminated against and/or whose ancestors never discriminated, and those whose ancestors genuinely were or did. There is no justification in terms of ending poverty or preventing the development of an elite class: studies show that, on balance, racial preferences hurt the poor and help the rich, systematically excluding poor whites while mostly aiding upper-class minorities. If income level were the criterion instead of race, black participation in the best colleges would fall from 8 to 4 percent, Hispanic from 8 to 6.

But at least there's "diversity." Or is there? Granted that "diversity" in itself is a good thing--something that could easily be debated--a study by Thomas Espenshade and Alexandria Radford, calculating the effects of "affirmative action" at eight elite US colleges, suggests that the current practices actually reduce ethnic diversity at said campuses. (Robert VerBruggen, "Racial Preferences by the Numbers," National Review Online, November 30, 2009).

This is not a conclusion of the study; and this fact itself makes the data presented seem more reliable. There is no axe honing here. But it is clear in the figures. Stay with me here.

If racial preferences were eliminated at the private colleges studied, Espenshade and Radford calculate that the number of "white" students would not go up--it would go down. "Whites" would drop from 60 to 53 percent of the student body at the most prestigious colleges. So would the number of "black" students: from 8 to 3 percent. "Hispanics" would drop from 8 to 5 percent. But "Asians" would jump from 24 to 39 percent.

Look at those numbers, and one fact is clear: the major effect of current racial preferences is not to help blacks or Hispanics--the numbers there are trivial--but to harm Asians. These quotas, whatever the official justification, work exactly like the earlier quotas against Jews.

Taking "whites" as the mainstream, the raw "diversity" without racial preferences is seven percent greater--the difference between 40 percent and 47 percent "other." But that is only a partial picture: for the categories traditionally used are themselves fairly arbitrary. In America, there is a great deal more cultural diversity within the category "Asian" than within "black." With all due respect, as Martin Luther King insisted, most American blacks differ from most American whites in little more than skin colour. They speak the same language, belong to the same religion, eat the same foods, play the same sports, listen to the same music, and watch the same TV.

But "Asians" are fairly likely to be fresh-off-the-airplane immigrants, or first or second-generation immigrants, with genuinely different attitudes and life experiences. Different religions, different mother tongues, different foods, different sports, different cultures. And within this group is a-near-infinity of further differences: an "Asian" might be Japanese, Chinese, Korean, Filipino, Indian, Sri Lankan, Bengali, Indonesian, Thai, Vietnamese, Pakistani, Iranian, Central Asian, Burmese, Arabian; a wide variety of very different countries and cultures, covering half the world's population and three of the four traditional world civilizations.

Really, trust me, guys: all foreigners are not the same.

That's what we are blocking out with racial preferences. Given their international reputation, if America's most exclusive colleges stayed strictly with merit, they would draw the best and the brightest from the entire world, and be about as diverse. By cheapening their degrees with racial preferences, they prevent this.

The same is true for less-well-known institutions: if you want real diversity, the surest path is to concentrate on merit and merit alone as your entrance criterion.

Fox University

Does Fox News (of all places) have lessons for higher education?

Lecturing is out of vogue among educationists. The rule I hear is that no "chalk and talk" (as it is disparagingly called) should ever last more than twenty minutes, or it outlasts everyone's patience attention span.

This seems wrong. Firstly, the lecture has been standard educational practice in just about every culture for the past two or three thousand years; it seems unlikely that all the smartest of our ancestors could have been so wrong. Secondly, this surely has to vary with the skill of the lecturer--some people are a lot more interesting to listen to than others. Thirdly, Glenn Beck.

Like him or not, Beck currently has the highest rating on American all-news TV. And what he usually does is nothing but a good old fashioned traditional lecture, generally about history or civics, complete with chalk and blackboard--and yes, also with some nice audiovisuals, just as are currently available to anyone in any classroom with a computer and projector.

Beck is as aware of this as anyone--he's recently launched "Beck University," where avid viewers can get more of the same, from other lecturers.

Imagine that--attending university lectures not just as a purely profit-making venture, sans state subsidies, but a media sensation. Try that with your own undergraduates.

Perhaps Beck overdramatizes; perhaps he employs a lot of rhetorical tricks. But so should any good lecturer. There is no virtue in being dry.

Ironically, Beck himself claims to suffer from attention deficit disorder. That may have been his best teacher.

In an important way, this is a return to the origins of the university itself. In ancient Athens, teachers won their students by lecturing in the public square--just as Beck is doing. In the Medieval university, public lectures were still public entertainment, and professors built their reputations on how many listeners they could draw.

There was one other component to the Medieval university: disputation. Public debates were commonly held, widely subscribed, and holding forth competently in one was the test for graduation. This tradition remained important into the nineteenth century, in, for example, the Oxford Union.

Interestingly enough, this too is something Fox News has revived: having representatives for both points of view on camera at once, presenting point and rebuttal live. And this too audiences clearly still love: it is Bill O'Reilly's standard formula, and he ranks number two in ratings for all of American all-news TV.

So, put aside all political considerations: I propose Fox News as a model for making university good fun, and for forcing all academic ideas to be tested dirctly in the crucible of the marketplace. It would end the odd and ever-growing separation between the gown and the town, which ill-serves both. And the Internet, above all, makes it possible.

All lecturers should and probably soon will attract students by posting sample lectures online for free. The best will prosper.

Students will choose courses lecturer by lecturer, rather than signing up for one college and taking what they get. They will then combine credits as they go to achieve a certification.

Live debates among major figures in each field, with live questions from the audience, could and should be held regularly; students and the interested public could track the developments without the superimposition of any distorting lens.

True, all this is only half of the equation, or less: there is no interactivity in any of it. True learning is not just a spectator sport. But for dealing with the spectator part, all this seems pretty ideal. And the Internet's ability to generate interactivity and constructivism, the other part, is already pretty well understood.

Trinity Western's Statement of Faith

As far as I know, the blacklisting of Trinity Western University is still on. The Canadian Association of University Teachers became alarmed last fall about the private Christian campus' longstanding requirement for a statement of faith from all professors, running more or less along the lines of the Apostles' Creed. This, says CAUT, is a violation of academic freedom.

Maybe so; it certainly does restrict faculty membership to those with specific beliefs. On the other hand, it is hard to see how a university could ensure a "Christian" character without something like this. Can't universities differentiate themselves in such ways? What about a college that, as my own does, advertises a "student-centred approach" in the classroom? Does it have no right to ask faculty to be, in fact, "student-centred"? What about any college that has any kind of mission statement?

Prohibiting such statements would, firstly, force a homogeneity on higher education which would kill diversity--a stated goal of higher education currently in the US. It would also take all educational choices out of the hands of students, paying parents, taxpayers, or the public, and pool them entirely in the hands of the priesthood of university professors. This seems a poor choice for a democracy.

In fact, the CAUT's claims seem to have no legal merit. So far as I know, Canada has no statute law on academic freedom; hence, the authority becomes other major English-speaking jurisdictions: Britain and the US. In the US, the precise terms of academic freedom are set out in an agreement between professors and institutions, the "1940 Statement of Principles on Academic Freedom and Tenure." This document expressly permits "limitations of academic freedom because of religious or other aims," so long as they are "clearly stated in writing at the time of the appointment." Trinity Western is in clear compliance. In Britain, academic freedom is understood to reside with the institution, not the individual professor. Again, Trinity Western is in clear compliance--and, in fact, CAUT is in violation of its academic freedom.

It is also hard to see, as a practical matter, how one can get or give an education without some agreement on what education, and education's purpose, is. You can't take a trip without going somewhere. There has to be _some_ shared core of values; it is only a question of what it is, and whether all colleges and universities should or must have the same values, or whether they can or should differ from institution to institution.

That, and the fact that we should be aware, honest, and up-front about our values, as Trinity Western is, and should give other views a fair hearing.

Just this, CAUT itself apparently does not do. For there are other "faith statements" floating around that apparently do not trouble the CAUT. The following example is from a US campus--but, given the overall political climate in Canada, and our generally lesser protections for free speech, there are surely worse Canadian examples to be found. At the University of Massachusetts at Amherst, the Office of Equal Opportunity and Diversity [sic] asks search committees to ask all faculty applicants questions like the following:

"How have you demonstrated your commitment to women?"

"Which of your achievements in the area of equity for women gives you the most satisfaction?"

"How would you demonstrate your concern for equity for women if you were hired?"

"In your opinion, what are the three major problems for women on your campus?"

"How are general issues in higher education related to women's issues? What is the link?"

And so on, for something like a page.

The point of these questions, the document explains, is to determine "if a candidate is aware of and responsive to minority and women's issues.... When prospective employees are asked 'are you concerned about and supportive of these issues?' they will invariably give an affirmative reply. Unfortunately, that gives little indication of their level of concern or commitment. ... These questions will, therefore, be useful in drawing out the candidate's opinions rather than the 'correct answer.'"

In other words, this goes far beyond requiring a statement of faith--and well into inquisition.

My source for this document is "Want to Teach? Then Tell Us Your Politics," at Minding the Campus (www.mindingthecampus.com).

There's lots more where this came from, though. Consider the University of Minnesota, which requires all graduating Education majors--and hence, all faculty-- must be able to "discuss their own histories and current thinking drawing on notions of white privilege, hegemonic masculinity, hetero-normativity, and internalized oppression." (Foxnews.com, December 10, 2009).

And consider this: unlike Trinity Western, these are public universities, funded with tax dollars, not just by those who agree with the opinions required.

CAUT, are you listening? Where are your principles now? Can we have an investigation into such hiring practices, please?

Thoughts on the Adoption of Educational Technology

Change is all around us, in this brave new Web 2 world; how do we handle change management? As it happens, perhaps Web 2.0 itself shows the way. Perhaps the key to all successful change is to think 2.0; think collaboration. And perhaps “change management” is an oxymoron.

New technology and change does not usually work top-down. Most of the big breakthroughs in computing, or even in science, have happened in some kid’s garage, or on someone’s personal time for private projects. It has not often happened in big, established organizations. This being so, it is important _not to try hard to control it_. Any attempt at control imposes a barrier on those wishing to adopt change; while, conversely, trying to force others to change generally only builds resistance.

An example: almost every speaker at a recent IT conference I attended ran into trouble with their presentations, because they were all using the latest version of Flash, and all the lab computers at that venue—a technical college--were using a previous version. Their problem could have been relatively easily solved had they been able to update Flash on the computers themselves; but this was blocked by the IT Support department. It would not have happened at all of the computers were set to update such software automatically from the Web, as can be easily done. Too much control was inhibiting the use of the newest technology.

One of the presenters observed that at the high school where he currently worked, apart from automatic updating, they have the students download all the needed software themselves. This saves a huge amount of man-hours and money, ensures that everything is current, and teaches the students at the same time.

Accordingly, we could probably go a long way towards encouraging faster adoption of new technology simply by reducing our efforts.

For example:

1. Colleges probably need have no separate filtering of internet sites. For one thing, this filtering can be disastrous for any teacher using a particular website in the class—which is suddenly blocked halfway through the term. Such experiences then discourage any experimentation in future. College students are adults. We should, moreover, be disseminating knowledge, and encouraging inquiry, on principle, not blocking it. And why make extra work for ourselves?

2. Colleges should, similarly, probably have no restrictions on who uploads what to any LMS, at least among college employees. Thousands of Web 2.0 sites, and the wiki experience, have demonstrated that there is no need for this. A decent search function and a properly phrased search can instantly navigate even the worst organization of materials. If it is found desirable, later users or assigned editors can go through periodically and correct or delete what is clearly _not_ suitable, after the fact—with fair warning to all beforehand, and accessible backup for a reasonable period. But people will at least have had those materials in the meantime for their use. This is the model successfully followed by Web 2.0 sites such as Wikipedia or YouTube.

3. Neither colleges nor schools should have any restrictions on downloading to office computers, and for colleges, even lab computers. Doing so obviously prevents the adoption of new technology, and nothing substantial is gained thereby. If the IT Support department ghosts all systems regularly, it should be a simple matter to restore any system to an earlier point if and when downloads cause difficulties.

4. Students are, by and large, more computer literate than faculty. Why not exploit this by leaving more to the students—indeed, even by relying on students to train instructors? This in turn fits well with our common agenda of being student-centred, and with current pedagogical theories of “constructivism.” For example, we could bypass the whole issue of language labs, which then have to be maintained, by simply issuing all students with a tablet or laptop, even at their own expense, and leaving it to them to maintain them and install necessary software. If we have a good strong wireless network across campus, we have thereby made every classroom a computer lab, which is as it should be in this day and era. If not, we at least have a computer lab anywhere for the price of a modem and a few telephone cables.

This step would also probably instantly release the college from any need to police copyright from unrestricted downloading and uploading.

Less control over even non-technological aspects of campus organization could increase the rate of adoption of new technology. Whenever an institution imposes a college-wide or department-wide procedure, it will necessarily hold back any faculty who have discovered a higher-tech, more efficient way to do something. Instead of being able to exploit this greater efficiency, they are forced by such general standards, if they want to use the new technology, to do the same thing twice: once the new way, and then again in the old way. This eliminates all possible advantages of any private innovation or initiative. And it is intrinsically unlikely, given the nature of technological innovation, that the college-wide or department-wide approach will at any time be the most technologically advanced and efficient. If, on the other hand, one employee finds a significantly more efficient way of doing something, if let alone, other employees will generally see it as in their self-interest to adopt it, and the idea will quickly spread. Better mousetraps tend to lead to beaten paths.

Accordingly, from the viewpoint of encouraging adoption of technology, any campus-wide systems, no matter how high-tech, should probably whenever possible be voluntary and designed as an aid to employees, compulsoryand a requirement. We can make sure all the tools are in place for those instructors who are prepared to use them; we should not let those who are resistant to change hold back the rest. But at the same time, it seems likely to be counterproductive in several ways to compel the use of a given technology by instructors.

Training is obviously another vital issue. Yes, training is needed. But here again, quite possibly, less is more. Busy instructors do not generally have the extra time for formal training at specific times, and requiring this will probably only build resistance to change. Tight schedules generally do not allow many people to get together at any one time. And training received when it is not needed is wasted--it is forgotten soon. Any training, therefore, must be focused tightly on the principle that a payoff in saved time should be immediately visible to the participant. This calls for “just in time” training available as needed from Web 2.0 itself: the medium here is indeed the message, and here of all places we should be modelling the use of the technology available.

A great deal of such training is already available, in fact, on the web, and in a variety of formats. Therefore, if employees can simply be taught how to search the Web efficiently, they can find it for themselves, and in a format that best suits them, and at precisely the time they need it. As the old saying goes, “Give a man a fish, and he eats for a day. Teach him to fish, and he eats for the rest of his life.” Accordingly, only one clear and simple focus may be sufficient for all faculty or employee IT training.

It may all be easier than we imagine.