The Resurrection of the Humanities

I keep hearing about the Death of the Humanities. Nobody is studying them any more. The stats are striking.

But this is probably because nobody is teaching them any more. The truth is, we deliberately killed the humanities about fifty years ago, by government action in Canada, in the US by neglect. Universities are just such conservative institutions that it takes a few generations for the death notice to appear.

This was a fatal blunder. The humanities are meant to be the capstone of any education, and hence of any university. We need the humanities to know what is true, and what is worth studying. We need the humanities to know what an education is. If we do not know what is true or what is real, philosophical or theological questions, there is no cause to study one thing over another.

We cut off the heads of our colleges. They went mad with postmodernism and psychotherapy and scientism and fringe politics, random delusions. That is where we are now—with spiralling costs as things are no longer done out of principle, but purely for money. The humanities may have been first to lose their appeal with students—logically enough, as they were the first to be hollowed out—but many are talking now of an “education bubble” that looks about to burst on all faculties. The conventional university has become unsustainable.

Up to the Sixties, in Canada, each university knew what was real and what an education was because each university, with only a few exceptions, was confessional—it had a definite religious point of view, it had meaningful founding principles, which were supposed to guide all that it did. That was, largely, the reason for having different universities in the first place. We systematically demolished that, in Canada, in a deliberate postware drive to secularize education, and now are reaping the whirlwind.

Just for interest, here's a quick historical primer:

Queen's University—Presbyterian

McMaster University—Baptist

Wilfred Laurier University—Lutheran

University of Windsor—Catholic

University of Western Ontario—Anglican

University of Ottawa—Catholic

University of Toronto—a consortium, with colleges representing each denomination.

University of Manitoba—a consortium of Catholic, Anglican, and Presbyterian colleges. The Methodists originally were also included, but later split off as the University of Winnipeg.

Universite de Moncton—Catholic

Mount Allison University—Methodist

St. Thomas University—Catholic

Acadia University—Baptist

Mount Saint Vincent University—Catholic

Saint Francis Xavier University—Catholic

St. Mary's University—Catholic

Universite Sainte-Anne—Catholic

UPEI—formed as a merger of two preexisting institutions, one Catholic, one Protestant.

Bishop's University—Anglican

Concordia University—a merger of a Catholic and a YMCA college.

Universite de Montreal—Catholic

Universite de Sherbrooke—Catholic

Universite Laval—Catholic

University of Regina—Methodist

Secular universities:

Dalhousie University

University of New Brunswick

University of British Columbia

McGill University

The provincial universities in Western Canada were established more or less on the American model of secular state universities, and were non-denominational. In addition, any university founded postwar was almost automatically secular—until recently.

In the US, the deliberate government elimination of religious influence and of the religious character of universities did not take place; but nominally denominational universities mostly lost their denominational character more or less spontaneously at about the same period. I went to Syracuse University in NY in the late Seventies. It still had odd vestigial traces of its original Baptist character in the Religion Department—most of the professors were still Baptist ministers. But none of them taught, or admitted to believing in, Baptist theology.

The loss of so much heritage and tradition is sad; though not nearly as sad as the loss of so much meaningful education. We have lost, in effect, at least two generations of thinkers, writers, leaders, and artists. We have lost our way as a culture. Individually, we have been swamped by “mental illness.” To paraphrase Leonard Cohen, it ought to be clear to anyone from the raw statistics that some great catastrophe has taken place in the spiritual world since about the Second World War.

Happily, however, there has been a revival of religious colleges in more recent years. The humanities may be dying in these older legacy schools. But these new schools, though small, are booming. And they are centred on the humanities in their true, ancient form, the Great Books and Great Thoughts approach, guided by a coherent visoin of what man is and why he is here.

The problem, in other words, was never with the humanities. It was with the universities.

I predict a general renaissance in the humanities soon. It should have come long ago, had the devil's wrecking ball not been so hard at work. With increased prosperity, our culture has more time and resources for the finer things in life, more time for contemplation, and this is the sphere of the humanities. With the accelerating pace of technology, a practical degree actually makes less and less sense—all the details will be obsolete more or less by time of graduation, even on the vain hope that one's professors actually still know anything relevant based on their education much longer ago. The only workable approach is to focus on the fundamentals, on how to learn, how to evaluate, how to communicate, and how to make decisions. Everything else will more or less necessarily be on the job, or in night school.

We would know this, if we were not running around with our heads cut off.